If you ask employees what HR’s job is, you’ll probably hear: “To help us.” Ask the executives, and they’ll say: “To serve the business.” The problem? Both are right. And that’s exactly why HR is stuck in an impossible balancing act, constantly flipping between advocate and enforcer, protector and executioner.
So, is HR the guardian of company interests or the champion of employee well-being? The short answer: both. The long answer? Well, let’s get into it.
HR walks a tightrope between two seemingly opposing forces:
The catch? These two priorities often collide. One day, HR is setting up wellness programs and employee engagement surveys. The next, they’re handing out pink slips or enforcing unpopular policies.
HR’s Allegiance Shifts Hourly
Depending on the situation, HR must switch gears constantly. One moment they’re ensuring employees get the benefits they deserve, the next they’re advising leadership on cost-cutting measures. This constant back-and-forth creates distrust—employees see HR as puppets of management, while leadership sometimes sees HR as overly sympathetic to staff.
The “Two Bosses” Problem
HR isn’t just answering to one entity. They serve both executives and employees, often caught between conflicting demands. If they lean too far towards business interests, they’re labeled as corporate enforcers. If they push too hard for employee rights, they risk being sidelined by leadership.
Legal Liability vs. Ethical Responsibility
HR isn’t just about keeping people happy; it’s also about keeping the company out of legal trouble. Employment laws dictate many of their actions, whether it’s handling terminations, enforcing compliance policies, or responding to workplace disputes. Sometimes, this means making decisions that are legally sound but ethically uncomfortable.
HR’s Influence Depends on Leadership
How much power HR truly has varies wildly between companies. Some organizations see HR as a strategic partner, integrating them into high-level decision-making. Others treat HR like glorified admin staff, using them to handle paperwork and execute top-down decisions without pushback.
So, how can HR navigate this impossible balancing act without alienating one side or the other?
Be Transparent About Priorities
Employees and leadership need to understand that HR serves both interests. Being upfront about this can help manage expectations. HR should clearly communicate why certain decisions are made, even if they’re unpopular.
Strengthen HR’s Strategic Role
The more HR is integrated into company strategy, the better they can advocate for policies that benefit both employees and the business. If HR is involved in decision-making early on, they can push for solutions that are sustainable rather than reactionary.
Develop Separate HR Functions
Some companies have HR professionals dedicated to employee relations, separate from those handling business operations. This allows employees to feel they have a genuine advocate while keeping business-focused HR staff aligned with company goals.
Empower Employees with Data and Communication
HR often has access to company-wide insights on engagement, turnover, and satisfaction. Instead of keeping these insights behind closed doors, HR should share relevant data with employees and leadership alike, using it to push for fair and effective policies.
Encourage Leadership to See HR as More Than a Compliance Department
Executives need to understand that HR isn’t just there to process payroll and enforce policies. When HR is treated as a true partner, the entire organization benefits—from stronger workplace culture to improved retention rates.
HR’s job isn’t black and white—it’s a constant negotiation between business realities and employee needs. They can’t always be the heroes, nor should they always be the enforcers. The key is balance: ensuring that business objectives and employee well-being align as much as possible.
The challenge? Doing all of that while being seen as trustworthy by both sides.
No pressure, right?
Commenting Rules: Being critical is fine, if you are being rude, we’ll delete your stuff. Please do not put your URL in the comment text and please use your PERSONAL name or initials and not your business name, as the latter comes off like spam. Have fun and thanks for your input.
Join a growing community. Every Friday I share the most recent insights from what I have been up to, directly to your inbox.
